Child-led weaning is not the same as baby-led weaning. So there is no confusion, baby-led weaning is allowing a baby to feed themselves solids and skipping purees and spoon feeding. We used baby-led weaning with Liam as he refused to be spoon fed and never allowed purees. He still won't eat anything that doesn't crunch and needs to be chewed (it is part of his sensory issues). Child-led weaning is allowing a nursling to decide when they are ready to wean from breastfeeding. Kellymom shows that only 36% of mothers are nursing after 6 months, 17% are still nursing after the 1st birthday, and less than 6 % still nursing after 18 months.
Kellymom Source By contrast, Kathy Dettwyler, an anthropologist who studied nursing across cultures and mammal species, estimates that a natural age of weaning of humans is between 2.5 and 7 years of age.
Kathy Dettwyler
So why did I decide to follow child-led weaning and place myself in a tiny percentage of women nursing past 18 months? Remember I said when pregnant with Liam that I would wean him no later than 6 months. Ben nursed until 28 months, so my thinking changed alot somewhere along the way.
Safety note about this photo: I was not sleeping with the sheets since Ben was newborn. He fell asleep nursing and Dave wanted to capture the co-sleeping but covered me.
When Ben was born, I was hoping to nurse until age 2. I wasn't sure whether I would then gently wean him or follow his lead. I was not happy with the way Liam weaned suddenly due to a nursing strike. Thankfully, Ben took right to nursing at the hospital. Even more surprising, Ben was a fast nurser which meant he wasn't constantly attached to me and he even chose to nurse every 3 hours. Nursing him was so easy.
At 3 weeks Ben started crying inconsolably. If I had known then that random crying and screaming would last 2 years, I am not sure I could have survived it. The first pediatrician said colic, but a few weeks later, a second ped said it was reflux. We started with Zantac and it made no difference. His dosage was increased and increased again. Nothing made a difference. I eliminated dairy and soy from my diet. By 4 months, we were all weary. Ben started spitting up blood. Blood tests confirmed internal bleeding and we finally got a referral to a pediatric GI.
These photos were taken in January 2011 when Ben was 21 months.
The GI put Ben on Prilosec and it reduced the crying from 6 to 7 hours a day to 3 hours a day. 3 hours of crying a day is alot, and by this time, he was almost 6 months. His weight was not maintaining on a curve. He was born around 30th percentile and went up to 50th percentile by 2 months. Between 2 and 4 months, he fell 42 percentile points to 8th percentile. He fell even further over the next couple of months to 2nd percentile. The GI suggested that I formula feed. I requested a 2nd opinion.

The 2nd GI did not think I should supplement with formula but did make me talk to a nutritionist to ensure that I was consuming enough calories to support a nursling. The trial of going of milk and soy lasted about 4 months and did nothing to reduce Ben's crying so I started consuming them again. There were no changes to Ben in amount of crying. Ben still wasn't gaining weight as expected. The 2nd GI was convinced that reflux wasn't an issue and tested Ben for every disorder possible that causes growth issues. Time and again, the tests showed Ben was healthy. He was still crying hours a day. Dave was deployed and I was worn out. Ben wouldn't take a bottle so I didn't leave him at all basically. I constantly questioned whether I was making the right choice.

We made it to the 1 year milestone and Ben was still nursing. He was also still spitting up every day, sometimes multiple times, and often solid food rather than breast milk. The 2nd GI wanted to trial Ben off the Prilosec. The trial went horribly; Ben stopped sleeping, refused solids, and went back to screaming 6 hours a day. The GI tried to put him on Zantac and it made no difference. Ben went back on the Prilosec but was still refusing solids and solely nursing. His sleep wasn't improving, and he was still crying alot. But something was going right: he was gaining weight. At 14-18 months, eating little other than breast milk and kefir, his growth went from the 4 or 5th percentile all the way up to the 20th percentile.

In the meantime, we had moved so we needed to see a new GI. This time we had to travel 3000 miles to get there. This GI tripled Ben's Prilosec dosage and at 19 months he finally started sleeping through the night. With the Prilosec and Early Intervention OT, he started to eat more. The crying didn't decrease. Ben was scoped in January and it showed his esophagus is healthy. The GI wanted to take him off Prilosec. I asked for a 2nd opinion again. I also started taking him to a chiropractor. Ben was still spitting up weekly at 22 months old and as I mentioned had bouts of unexplained screaming.

The 4th GI agreed to leave him on Prilosec until after his 2nd birthday. His 2 year well baby showed that his growth was catching up to his peers, especially his height. Sometime after he turned 2, the uncontrollable crying stopped. In addition, I met the milestone I set for myself: I nursed Ben until he turned 2. He only nursed twice a day so I saw no reason to stop. Over the last few months, Ben went down to nursing once a day to every other day. By June, he was nursing once or twice a week. It is August 7th and he has nursed once this month so far, and I don't expect he'll nurse at all in September.
We are done. After supporting a baby with my body in pregnancy or nursing continually since December 2006, I am a happy to have my body belong to me again. But since we are done making babies, I am sad to say good-bye to nursing. Of all mothering things, it is the one that comes most natural to me. I struggle getting my boys to sleep close to a normal amount. Neither of them eat well or much. I struggle with issues related to discipline and what is typical development. Nursing is easy.
I am glad that I kept an open mind about length of nursing.